A Big, Silly Distraction

In Suzanne Collins’s wildly popular Hunger Games books, children are chosen by lottery to serve as gladiators who fight to the death.  The Games are televised for the entertainment of the general population.  Collins models her games on ancient Rome, where gladiators fought to the death and slaves were fed to the lions.  She even names her dystopian world Panem, after the Latin word for bread, as in bread and circuses, panem et circenses.  Bread and circuses refers to the cheap trick of persuading the masses to cheer for a lion or a slave, for one gladiator or another, rather than participating in or observing or acting to change the political arenaKeep the general population fed with the most basic of food and keep their minds off of rebellion with the distractions of entertainment.

As I read through Lenore Skenazy’s blog and watched her appearances on various chat shows, I kept thinking, “Bread and circuses.”  There is so much air time to fill, so television producers and headline writers make news of the Mommy Wars.  Free Range Parenting vs. Helicopter Parenting.  Stay-at-home Mothers vs. Working Mothers.  Breast vs. Bottle.  Sleep Training vs. Attachment Parenting.  Blah, blah, blah.  In one blogger’s take on the issue, she asks, “Free range parenting versus helicopter parenting: which team are YOU on?”  Really?  We have to pick teams?  These issues are so much more complex than x vs. y, but so much easier to digest if packaged in a familiar us vs. them format.

Image credit

In one clip, Skenazy and another parent appear on Anderson Cooper to replay how Skenazy was able to help this woman who is so much of the helicopter persuasion that in public washrooms she feels it necessary to go right into the bathroom stall with her daughter.  “Doesn’t everybody?”  this mother quips, when the audience gasps.  They feed this woman to the lions, then they rescue her, undo her public shame with a public reformation of her extreme and errant ways.

Unless it’s extreme, it’s not entertainment, so we have thown up on the screen all kind of wild and wacky folk on reality shows who hoard or dumpster dive for coupons for hundreds of free sticks of deodorant, saving up against Armageddon.

What good does any of this do?  Silly distractions from the reality lived in the murky middle ground.

I respect Skenazy and her husband’s decision to let their son ride the subway alone.  I respect her desire to move away from a culture where kids are kept bubble wrapped.  I respect her initiative to create a television show that capitalizes on the buzz that her son’s subway ride generated.  But I resent the circus atmosphere of telling the stories of bubble wrapped or free range kids.

Why do mothers keep feeding each other to the lion of artificially polarized public opinion?

Blogosphere Round-Up!

We here at 4mothers1blog like blogs. We like other people’s blogs just about as much as we like our own, which is to say, a whole lot. Here are five posts we think you should be reading:

“God, I love it when your breath smells like Gaviscon” — Porn for Pregnant Ladies (from Pregnant Chicken)

“I get to wear those?!” C.J. said smiling.
“Yup.”
“ALL OF THEM?!” he squealed looking at the tub of about 100 pink lost and found ballet shoes.
“No, silly, just two, you only have two feet.” – “My Son, the Dancer” (from Raising My Rainbow)

This post is a couple of years old now, but it about sums it up. Ten Things I Hate About Motherhood (And One That I Love) (from Her Bad Mother)

The Hidden Mother — a practice in photography of old. To ensure that a young child didn’t move during the long exposure, the mother held the child tightly; all the while, she was hidden by a blanket, not being the obvious subject of the photo. Worth a look ( via A Cup of Jo and Retronaut)

And because it’s a new year: well, hello!

Hello from ant1mat3rie on Vimeo.

4mothers1blog on Babble’s Best Mommy Blogs

I think we may have one of you to thank for a nomination for Babble’s Best Mommy Blogs.  If you click through to the link and hit the alphabetical toggle, we are on the first page.  (And if you are so inclined, please “like” us and move us up the popularity rankings!!)

Thanks for reading, everyone.  This was a lovely surprise, and we’d love to welcome more readers.

Guest Post: Kerry Clare on Becoming a Compulsive Parenting Expert

This month, 4 Mothers will host several guest bloggers. 

Today, Kerry Clare from Pickle Me This writes, “When I was a compulsive parenting expert.” 

It was hard-won, all the wisdom I acquired during those urgent, blurry first few months of motherhood. I learned to breastfeed lying down, how to wear a baby in a sling, how to push a stroller up a step and into a shop, and how to change a diaper on a picnic table. I learned that our cheap baby carrier wasn’t very good, and that the money we’d spent on the stroller was worth it. I learned to launder cloth diapers, snap-on onesies, and install the car-seat. I learned how not to mind being covered in vomit all the time. And, most importantly, I learned how to breastfeed while holding a book, which was also how I learned to make my life my own again.

New motherhood was a re-education of how to be in the world, an awkward stage but a necessary one because the world with a baby in tow is an unexpectedly foreign place. By about six weeks, however, I was beginning to know the language. The culture was starting to seem familiar, and I was getting a sense of the rituals. You might say that I possessed a certain confidence, if you happened to define confidence as “clinging by one’s fingertips to some chaotic version of sanity while dangling dangerously over an abyss.” But I was clinging! I was clinging! Each day I held on was another milestone, and slowly, it was all becoming easier.

So basically, I was a parenting expert. Because I’d already figured out that the real so-called parenting experts didn’t know anything—at our house, Dr. Harvey Karp was fast re-christened “Dr. Douchebag”, and I’ll own up to having whispered a few things less than charitable about the late Tracy Hogg. I’d figured out that babies aren’t something that can be learned from a book, that parenthood’s steep learning curve has no shortcuts to climbing. However, I’d climbed so far in such a short time that the view was already impressive, and I decided that I would make my own journey doubly worthwhile by sharing what I’d seen.

I figured that my experience could save my pregnant friends a lot of trouble. I’d tell them, “Don’t let the nurses in the hospital push you around. Just forget about the bassinette, and bring the kid to bed. Have lots of soothers on hand, and you might even sleep once in a while. Don’t eat broccoli, or you’ll give the baby gas, then the baby will cry for three days straight until you learn to pump its legs to make it fart. Get a bedtime routine set fast and early. Get a breast pump, but rent one, don’t buy it.”

I told them, “And be prepared to feel like a cow. Be prepared to cry, and cry. It’s going to be awful, I’m not going to lie to you. But you’re going to get through it, I promise. I sit here feeding my screaming infant and lecturing you as living-proof that one day everything is going to be okay. Oh, and by the way, I’ve gone through your registry and crossed off all the stuff you don’t need, and made a note about everything you’ve missed.”

It was a compulsion, I will admit, the way I insisted on hunting down women in their third trimesters of pregnancy, and horrifying them with stories of how terrible their lives were about to become. But really, I wasn’t responsible for my behaviour in their presence. The very sight of their burgeoning bellies, their innocent bliss, how they kept talking about looking forward to getting the baby out so they could finally get a good night’s sleep again—it would fill me with overwhelming dread, and I’d start displaying symptoms of PTSD.

 I was only trying to help. It’s true. Though I understand how it appeared that I was a dictator, or worse, that I was projecting my own terrible introduction to motherhood onto others in an attempt to validate my own experiences. I understand why some of these friends stopped calling after a while, but I promise that my sole motivation was only ever altruism. It’s just that whenever I imagined my friends in those first few weeks, as stranded, stretched and alone as I had felt, I’d become some kind of zealot, desperate to pass on the knowledge I’d acquired so that they too could be saved. I’d forgotten that each mother has to come by this knowledge in her own way, and that my expert advice was about as useful as the Baby Whisperer’s.

I wish I could say that my compulsion went away with the post-partum crazies, or even that I’d stopped by the end of my daughter’s first year. I kind of wish that I wasn’t stalking the woman around the corner who’s been pushing a stroller around the neighbourhood for a few weeks now, looking a little bit shattered, but I can say that I’m doing my best to leave her alone. I am still learning.

Of course, it’s easier, now that I’m no longer just barely clinging to sanity myself, now that I really do have enough confidence that it’s not so hard to see others making choices different from mine. I’ve got enough perspective these days to understand that my desperate warnings did no good because every woman’s experience of new motherhood will be entirely her own, re-invented over and over again. And what she needs from her friends is for them to listen, to validate her story, the good and the bad, and to urge her on in the amazing and miraculous tasks that she is performing every day.

Kerry’s essay about new motherhood, “Love Is A Let Down,” was nominated for a National Magazine Award.  Originally published in The New Quarterly, it will be re-published in Best Canadian Essays 2011.

It Takes a Village

One of the very best shower gifts my husband and I received when my eldest son was born was a voucher for a catering company (which has, sadly, since gone out of business).  It was all organic, homemade fare, healthy and delicious, but of course, the real gift was the gift of time and peace of mind.  On several nights in those first few crazy weeks, we did not have to think about what to make for dinner.  We could, instead, spend even more time getting to know the massive bundle of baby we had come home with.

One of the families at Rowan’s playschool has recently welcomed a new addition, and the families who form the co-op community got organized to make and deliver meals.   It is such a simple idea, and one which perhaps in our idealized sense of simpler times, may have happened naturally in a community when a baby arrived.  In the middle of the city and of busy lives, though, we sometimes forget how simple gestures can accumulate great power to make a neighbour’s life easier.  After a few organizing emails this family now has a roster of dinners arriving over the next two weeks.  Nourishment for body and soul.

If you are looking for an idea for a shower gift, try organizing a meals on wheels.  Pool resources and invest in a gift certificate for a meal delivery company, or organize neighbours to feed the family.  After both receiving and participating in this kind of thing, I can tell you that fewer things are more welcome, or more easy, than being part of the village that welcomes a child.

Why Don’t You Put a Blanket Over Your Face?

It rarely happens to me – being speechless.  I was sitting in Starbucks, cup in hand, and my mouth agape.  Eyes wide.  I could not believe what I had just heard – and trust me, I have heard a lot of crazy spew in my day.

On Monday evenings my son has cooking class with his best buddy and it just so happens that his mom is one of my best buddies. After the boys are aproned and spoons are in their hands, we practically trample over the gaggle of nannies signing-in their charges, to make the most of our alone time.

For forty-five minutes we gossip, vent, plan birthdays, and lament how we don’t fit into our skinny jeans since having our babies.  Recently a new girl joined our coffee-talk, my girlfriend’s five-month-old daughter.

Obviously being 5 months old her addiction to caffeine has not yet fully developed and after some moments of being fussy, communicating her desire for both sleep and food, my friend removed her own down vest, placed it on the chair behind her and facing me, discreetly pulled up her top to allow her baby to latch onto her breast.  Within seconds, her daughter was calmly nursing and the conversation returned to what skating lessons we’d be signing the boys up for.

That’s when it happened.  A man dressed in a suit and tie, obsessively fondling his iPad, looked up.  Red-faced, he extended his arms wide, as if to give a bear hug, and in a loud, obnoxious voice said, “Would you mind putting a blanket over you or something?  You’re making me very uncomfortable!”

That’s when the mouth dropped, the eyes bulged and all the witty comebacks retreated from the tip of my tongue.  I thought I was the only one having this reaction but I noticed a similar look on the mother of three sitting at the table next to us and the gum-smacking high-school girls behind us appeared more uncomfortable with his outburst than the feeding baby.

My friend mumbled that she didn’t realize he could see anything and reached for a blanket to cover her daughter’s face.

I never breastfed any of my three children but regardless I felt that this ignorant comment meant to shame was an attack on mothering.

First of all, breastfeeding a child is natural. If it makes you uncomfortable, then YOU turn away.  Breastfeeding does not have to take place in a dingy washroom stall or underneath a suffocating blanket so other people are made to feel comfortable.  I once saw a woman breastfeeding her baby while pushing a grocery cart.  I wasn’t uncomfortable at the sight of her bare breast; I was more in awe of her dexterity.  I am not able to talk on my phone and push the cart, never mind provide nourishment for my infant while plucking a box of Cheerios from the shelf.

Comments such as this and the one I received while bottle-feeding my infant son years ago (from a nosey witch well-meaning individual:  “Breast is best you know!”) further perpetuate the struggle that many mothers, especially new mothers have.  It’s hard enough being a mom without constant judgment from passersby.  My husband believes that this man never would have said anything to my friend had a man been with us because men, whether we like it or not, are held to a different social standard.  Had my husband been bottle-feeding our infant in public more likely than not he would have been perceived as a doting father, whereas I was practically hissed at.

Society bashes mothers over the head about the benefits of breastfeeding and to persevere through cracked, bleeding nipples, sleepless nights, and insufficient milk supply.  What new mothers don’t need is to be on the receiving end of boorish comments and sideway glances.

Once the mother sitting next to us recovered from shock, she silently offered her support with a thumbs-up.  After the baby had fallen asleep and was returned to her stroller, we got up to leave, the mood at coffee-talk definitely dampened.  When we walked passed the table with the man, who had been joined by female companion, my friend politely said, “I am sorry if you were uncomfortable but next time why don’t you move to another seat.”

Before she could even finish, right after the word “sorry” was spoken, he interrupted and replied, “Well, I appreciate you covering up.  I was very uncomfortable.”

Seeing that her message wasn’t heard, my hurt friend pushed her stroller out the door.  I couldn’t let this go.  I had to stand up for her and her daughter.  I looked at him, sitting there with a smug expression on his face, and this time let the witty comeback flow freely from my mouth:

“She was feeding her baby.  If it makes you so uncomfortable why don’t you go and sit in the corner with a blanket over your head.  That would make me feel more comfortable.”

photo credit: http://pregnancy.about.com/od/feedingyourbaby/ig/Breastfeeding-Gallery/